Loyal readers of this blog already know that I'm a fan of Mexican Coke, having espoused it's virtues in a previous
post. Melba made a trip to the
Midtown Global Market on Saturday and bought me four bottles of Mexican Coke, two bottles each from two different vendors. I brought two bottles to work with me today, and just happened to grab one of each. It wasn't until I examined them closely that I realized that they came from two different bottlers in Mexico and each had a slightly different content/nutrition label.
I don't really trust the labels that are slapped on these bottles - they're obviously put on as an afterthought to comply with US FDA nutrition labeling requirements, and are immediately suspect when they list "corn syrup and/or sugar" as an ingredient.
A perfect opportunity for a head-to-head taste test!

Here we have the two bottles of Mexican Coke, one from a bottler in Saltillo (in Coahuila, a northern state) and the other from a bottler in Acapulco (in Guerrero, a southern state).


That's the Saltillo cap and label, and...


...the Acapulco cap and label. We had to use a staple remover as a bottle opener. Not pretty.
So my cubemate and I lined up the two Mexican cokes and a 16 oz. American Coke out of the company soda (pop) machine for the test. The results:
Me:
1. Coahuila Mexican Coke
2. Acapulco Mexican Coke
79. American Coke
Cubemate:
1. Acapulco Mexican Coke
2. Coahuila Mexican Coke
91. American Coke
We both agreed that the Coahuila Mexican Coke has a slightly subtler taste to the Acapulco Coke's snappier Coke flavor. I preferred the subtler version, cubemate likes the snappier version. But we also agreed that they are quite similar and the differences tough to discern in anything other than a head-to-head taste test.
After alternating between the two Mexican Cokes, we braced ourselves for the intense mediocrity of the American Coke. Personally, I was surprised at how bland the American version is in comparison. I expected the high fructose corn syrup to lend a much stronger flavor bite, but we agreed that the American Coke is actually quite bland when compared to The Real Thing
TM sugar sweetened Cokes. Not to mention the filmy tooth sweaters left behind by HFCS. Yecch.